Technical brochure
TB 914 JWG B3/A3.59

Guidelines for SF6 end-of-life treatment of T&D equipment (>1 kV) in substations

Electrical equipment using SF6 as insulating and/or arc quenching gas is widely used globally since the second half of last century. Due to its superior technical performance, SF6 technology has been implement-ed in applications for medium voltage (MV, ≤52 kV) in distribution network, high voltage (HV, >52 kV) in bulk power generation and transmission, and all the way up to ultra-high voltage (1200 kV).

Members

Convenor (DE)

M. HYRENBACH

Secretary (UK)

T. LUJIA CHEN

A. GREEN (UK), A. LASO RUBIO (US), F. TRICHON (FR), F. ZENG (CN), G. KACHELRIESS (DE), J. STAGE (US), J. RAPP (UK), J. MANUEL INCHAUSTI SANCHO (ES), N. OTAKA (JP), P. FERNANDEZ (BR), R. KURTE (DE), S. LABERGE (CA), S. FLOOD (IE), T. DÜRR (DE), T. SCHWARZE (DE), T. UCHII (JP), U. AMMER (DE), Z. SMITH (US)

Even considering the very long lifetime of 40 to 50 years for electrical equipment, it is inevitable that equipment will reach their end-of-life (EoL). Alternatively, the gas quality indicates that heavily aged SF6 must be replaced to extend the equipment lifetime. An unexpected discovery when the SFtechnology had been implemented in the market was the extremely high global warming potential (GWP) that is 25,200 times the CO2 equivalent. Therefore, emission of the SFgas must be minimised and special precautions are necessary at the EoL management of SFcontaining electrical equipment, in terms of the final disposal procedures and/or recycling of SFand parts of such equipment.

Transmission System Operators (TSO) and Distribution System Operators (DSO) are electricity utilities with their own service departments and established experience in the handling of SFequipment and SFgas. This is not the case across the entire power industry as there are many smaller companies with perhaps only a few SFinstallations, far fewer handling experience and service personnel. For these companies, an environmentally sound EoL treatment guide is of great benefits. For distribution equipment, the quantity of SFper asset is relatively low for equipment at lower voltage levels due to their compact design. However, the number of units installed is extremely high, so the overall quantity of SFused in MV and HV is more or less the same. Therefore, it is imperative to develop guidelines that inform end-users the appropriate steps for all SFassets across different voltage levels to ensure minimal SFemissions.  

This guide summarises the well-known practices and inform the EoL procedure of handling electrical equipment containing SFand the SFitself. Every step of the process is explained in detail, from the preparation until recycling or final disposal. The target is to limit the SFemissions in every step of the processes dealing with the disposal of equipment parts and/or the recycling of SFused in all equipment reaching their EoL to the absolute bare minimum that is technically achievable. Importantly, safety must be guaranteed in every single step.

Checklists at the end of the brochure will support streamlined preparation of the work and in selecting appropriate partners to perform the work in the most professional and cost-effective manner. It needs to be highlighted that avoiding emissions of SFis stipulated in various regulations and local laws, and therefore this guide helps to comply with these rules and regulations to prevent sanctions or penalties for owners or operators of electrical equipment, and crucially avoid undesired impacts to the environment.

The brochure starts with some definitions on electrical equipment types and common technical expressions used throughout the Technical Brochure. Large HV switchgear are well known as products containing SFin high quantity, but also smaller equipment such as ring main units or even...

To read this article subscribe to ELECTRA. Single edition, annual options and CIGRE membership are available. Access to all editions is free for CIGRE members.

Already have an account? Sign in

Subscribe now

Study Committees

Joint Working Group

This Technical Brochure has been created by a Joint Working Group from the CIGRE Study Committees.

Learn more about our 16 Study Committees and domains of work
Top of page